American Express has stopped automatically pooling Membership Rewards points from a newly opened card into an existing balance. A new card that earns Membership Rewards now lands in its own separate account by default, which matters to anyone who combines points for transfers to airline and hotel partners.
What changed
For years, opening a new Membership Rewards card meant Amex recognized the cardholder and merged the new card's points with the existing balance. Updated program terms now put new cards in a separate Membership Rewards account unless the cardholder links them. Existing cards keep their current accounts and pooled balances.
How to link a new card
- The application flow offers a step to link the new card with existing Membership Rewards cards.
- After approval, the "Manage Connections" option on the Amex website or app handles pooling. It can take a few hours to appear.
- Amex can also link the accounts by phone.
Who it affects
If you're opening your first Membership Rewards card, nothing changes. If you already hold a card such as the Gold or Platinum and open another one, the new card's points sit apart until linked. Points in separate accounts can't be combined for a single transfer, so a booking that needs a bigger balance could be held up.
Why pooling matters
Membership Rewards is Amex's transferable points currency. Points can move to airline and hotel partners, and many transfer bonuses and award bookings need one balance large enough to cover the whole trip. A family that holds a personal card and a business card, for example, usually wants both earning into the same pool. Two small balances in two accounts are harder to use than one large one.
The open question
Amex hasn't said why the default changed. Some in the points community wonder whether it's groundwork for different transfer rules by card type, as Chase and Citi already do with some partners. That is speculation, and nothing from Amex confirms it.
The options
- If you're applying for another Membership Rewards card, linking during the application is the quickest route.
- If you already opened one recently, checking the account list for a second balance is a quick way to tell whether it was pooled.
- If you plan to close or downgrade a card, confirming where its points sit first avoids surprises.
Short videos on travel points are on YouTube at @PaulsPoints.