In the video, Sue just got a $470 reward certificate from her Costco credit card and thinks it's free money. Paul has the same card, but he only uses it for gas. Who's right? Both of them, sort of. The Costco card is a good deal in one place, and that place is Costco. Almost everywhere else, it pays very little.
What the Costco card actually earns
The card in the video is the Costco Anywhere Visa by Citi. As of October 2026, it earns:
| Where you spend | What you earn |
|---|---|
| Gas at Costco | 5% |
| Other gas and EV charging | 4% |
| Restaurants and travel | 3% |
| Costco and Costco.com | 2% |
| Everything else | 1% |
The 5% and 4% gas rates share a limit of $7,000 in spending a year. After that, gas earns 1%. There's no annual fee as long as you have a paid Costco membership.
Gas is the card's best trick, and shopping at Costco itself is a solid deal too. The problem is the bottom line.
Where your money really goes
Most families don't live at Costco, even if it feels like it. Think about where your money goes every month:
- The vet
- The phone bill
- Internet
- Insurance
- Streaming services
On the Costco card, all of that earns just 1%. You aren't losing money, but you are quietly missing out on rewards. Every one of those bills could earn more on a different card.
What a travel card does with the same spending
A travel card earns miles or points on everything you buy, including the regular, boring stuff. Many pay at least double what the Costco card pays on everyday bills: 2 points per dollar or more instead of 1%.
That means the vet counts. The phone bill counts. The internet bill counts. In the video, Paul says his everyday spending last year covered a flight. Not a big splurge, not a special purchase. Just the bills he was going to pay anyway.
The catch with the Costco reward
The Costco card's reward doesn't land in your bank account whenever you want it. It comes as a yearly reward certificate:
- Once a year. It arrives after your February statement closes.
- Cashed in at Costco. You take it to a U.S. Costco warehouse and use it for cash or merchandise there.
So you have to go to Costco to get your reward. That's fine if you shop there anyway. It's just not the same as rewards you can use for anything, or for a trip.
What about gas?
Gas is where this card shines. It pays 5% at Costco pumps and 4% at other gas stations and EV chargers, up to that $7,000 yearly limit. If your family drives a lot, that's a strong reason to keep the card in your wallet for fill-ups. Just remember the limit: past $7,000 of gas in a year, it drops to 1%.
The catch with travel cards
There's always a catch, and here it is: some travel cards have a yearly fee. So do the math first. If most of your spending is everyday stuff, a travel card can easily pay for itself. But check the fee against what you'll actually earn before you switch.
The simple plan
You don't have to cut up the Costco card. Keep it and use it where it shines:
- Costco card for Costco and gas
- Travel card for everything else
And that $470 certificate? Spend it at Costco. Obviously.
---
Short videos on travel points are on YouTube at @PaulsPoints.