In the video, Sue can't decide. Amex, Capital One or Chase? She's read every ad: big bonuses, airport lounges, one card is even made of metal. Every ad looks great, but that's kind of their job.

Paul and Michael's advice: stop comparing cards. When you pick a travel card, you're really picking a points program. And the way to pick a program is to answer three questions about yourself first. Not about the cards. About you.

Shop for a program, not a card

A program is a bank's own points. Every card from that bank that earns those points feeds the same pile. So the order is:

  1. Pick the pile (the program).
  2. Then pick the cards that feed it.

Once you know what you need from a program, the ads stop being confusing. They're just ads.

Question 1: Where do you want to go?

"Everywhere" isn't an answer. Narrow it down. Sue's answer: Italy someday, plus visits to her sister in Denver a couple of times a year. That's one big trip overseas and short trips at home, and that matters.

Here's why. Each bank lets you move your points to certain airlines and hotels. Those are its partners, and every bank has a different list. Some examples, as of October 2026:

  • Love Delta? Of these three banks, only Amex sends points to Delta.
  • Fly Southwest? Of these three, only Chase does.

If the airline you actually fly isn't on a program's list, that program can't get you there, no matter how good the ad looks.

And it's not just whether a partner is on the list. Do you actually like who's on it? A hotel you'd never stay at isn't a perk.

Question 2: Where does your money actually go?

This is where most people get it wrong. Sue's answer: groceries (so many groceries) and eating out.

That means she wants a program with cards that pay extra on groceries and dining, not just the one with the biggest bonus. Each program's cards pay extra in different places. For example, as of October 2026:

  • The Amex Gold card pays 4 points per dollar at restaurants and U.S. supermarkets (up to yearly limits).
  • The Chase Sapphire Preferred pays 3 points per dollar on dining, and also on gas stations and electric car charging.
  • The Capital One Venture pays 2 miles per dollar on everything.

Then there's the gas trap. Sue saw a card that pays 3 points on gas and got excited. One problem: she drives an electric car that she charges in her garage. So for her, that's three points on nothing. (Even on a card that counts electric car charging, like the Sapphire Preferred, that means paying at a charging station. Charging at home just shows up on your electric bill.)

Every ad brags about its best category. It only counts if you spend there.

An easy way to answer this question: look at your last three statements. Your money has already picked your categories.

Question 3: How many cards do you actually want?

Almost nobody asks this one, but you do get a choice.

  • Some programs work great with one card. Capital One's Venture cards, for example, earn the same rate on everything.
  • Others work best with two or three cards working as a team. Chase's no-fee Freedom cards usually pair with a Sapphire card, so their points can be moved to partners. Amex's main cards each favor different categories.

Keep in mind that every card is another app, another login and another statement to check. If you can't keep track of your streaming passwords, don't build a five-card system you'll forget about.

Two cards you actually use beat five you don't.

Putting the answers together

Here's where Sue ended up:

QuestionSue's answer
Where do you want to go?Italy someday, Denver a lot
Where does your money go?Groceries and eating out
How many cards do you want?Two, tops

She's no longer shopping for a card. She knows what she needs from a program. Write down your own three answers before you look at a single card ad. The next episode runs Chase, Amex and Capital One through these same three questions.

---

Short videos on travel points are on YouTube at @PaulsPoints.